Single Family for Sale: 91 New Island Avenue, Portland, ME 04108

4 beds
1 full baths
$530,000
$530,000
91 New Island Avenue, Portland, ME 04108
4 beds
1 full baths
$530,000
Remove from
Favorites
Add to
Favorites
Add to
Trip Map
Hide Share or
Email
Price:
$530,000

Type Single Family
Style Colonial
Beds 4
Total Baths 1 full baths
Square Feet 1,716 sqft
Lot Size 0.15 acres
Year Built 1900
Taxes Paid $7,248

City Portland
County Cumberland

MLS 1605956
Status Active Under Contract
DOM 49 days
Step into this charming antique Colonial on Peaks Island, a true gem built in 1900 and lovingly maintained. With 1,716 square feet of inviting living space across two levels, this 4-bedroom, 1-bathroom residence, complete with a classic clawfoot tub, exudes vintage elegance. The layout includes a formal dining room, living room with a fireplace, kitchen and office on the first floor with bedrooms upstairs, all connected by a central staircase. This home boasts high ceilings and large windows that allow natural light to pour in. Original built-ins bookcases throughout the first floor, original hardware, and a handcrafted mantel in the living room, add both character and functionality to the home. The dry basement, once used as a woodworking space, offers additional potential. Nestled on a .15-acre double lot, this property offers a rare chance to own a piece of Peaks Island at a great price, with valuable updates already in place—perfect for those looking for a one of a kind opportunity to personalize their dream space. Notable updates include a new roof in 2014, electrical improvements, a new hot water heater, an upgraded breaker panel, and electric baseboard heating in one of the upstairs bedrooms. A forced hot air furnace was installed in 2017, along with a thorough weatherization project. As a bonus, this home is already connected to public water and sewer services, with easy access to cable-perfect for those working from home. Enjoy the tranquil island setting from the charming enclosed porch, or entertain guests on the spacious deck. The yard provides an ideal canvas for creating your own outdoor oasis, perfect for relaxation or hosting gatherings. A quick walk takes you to the ferry and local eateries, offering the best of island living with easy access to city conveniences. Peaks Island, known for its rich history and vibrant community, is just a short ferry ride from Portland. Don't miss your chance to own this gem, schedule a private tour today!

Room Features

Bedroom 1 Second floor
Bedroom 2 Second floor
Bedroom 3 Second floor
Bedroom 4 Second floor
Dining Room First floor
Kitchen First floor
Living Room First floor
Office First floor
Other Room Second floor
Basement Description Full, Walk-Out Access, Unfinished, Interior Entry

Lot & Building Features

Cooling None
Tax Year 2025
Taxes Paid $7,248

Price History of 91 New Island Avenue, Portland, ME

Date Name Price Difference
10/09/2024 Listing Price $530,000 N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.

Comparable Properties Sold Near By

Low
$380,000
$223 / sqft
Average
$527,447
$309 / sqft
High
$680,000
$362 / sqft

Address City Zip Beds Baths Price Sq. Ft. $/SQFT Sold Date
This Listing Portland 04108 4 1.0 $530,000 1,716 $309 N/A
47 Marriner Street South Portland 04106 3 2.0 $513,970 1,674 $307 12/28/2023
229 Cottage Road South Portland 04106 4 2.0 $460,500 1,591 $289 12/04/2023
562 Sawyer Street South Portland 04106 4 1.0 $400,000 1,626 $246 02/09/2024
16 Cape Woods Drive #16 Cape Elizabeth 04107 3 2.0 $675,000 1,666 $405 04/22/2024
89 Davis Street South Portland 04106 4 2.0 $525,000 1,582 $332 06/07/2024
9 Haven Road South Portland 04106 4 1.0 $380,000 1,704 $223 06/10/2024
67 Elsmere Avenue South Portland 04106 4 2.0 $680,000 1,881 $362 08/01/2024
35 Providence Avenue South Portland 04106 4 1.0 $400,000 1,854 $216 08/02/2024
90 High Street South Portland 04106 3 2.0 $575,000 1,728 $333 08/22/2024
18 Emery Street South Portland 04106 4 2.0 $665,000 1,762 $377 10/03/2024

Map of 91 New Island Avenue, Portland, ME

Location Map Street View
Photo of Cheryl Waitt
Direct: 603-235-5521
Office
200 Rockingham Road.
Londonderry, NH 03053
603-437-4447
Listed by Portside Real Estate Group, Coleen Smith 207-846-4300
$
20%
1.3676094339623%
6.75%
$
$
$
Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Monthly Taxes
Monthly HOA
Monthly Home Ins.
Monthly PMI

91 New Island Avenue (MLS #1605956) is a colonial single family home located in Portland, ME. This single family home is 1,716 sqft and on a lot of 6,534 sqft (or 0.15 acres) with 4 bedrooms, 1 baths and is 124 years old. This property was listed on 10/04/2024 and has been priced for sale at $530,000.

The 4 bedroom single family home at 67 Elsmere Avenue in South Portland is nearby and sold for $680,000 on 08/01/2024. Another nearby 3 bedroom single family home, 16 Cape Woods Drive in Cape Elizabeth sold for $675,000 on 04/22/2024.

Nearby zip codes are 04050, 04101, 04106, 04107 and 04109. This property neighbors other cities such as Cape Elizabeth, Cumberland, Falmouth, Long Island and South Portland.

MREIS

Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listing information courtesy of: Portside Real Estate Group

Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Maine IDX and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified. ©2024 Maine Real Estate Information System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. This web site does not display complete Maine Listings. Certain Maine Listings of other real estate brokerage firms have been excluded.